AmbraVault and the most common alternatives
We compare a set of features on the basis of the vendors' public documentation. Where a feature depends on the plan, the licence or the configuration, we say so. Where we did not find enough information, we write “Not documented”: it does not mean the feature is missing.
| Capability | AmbraVault | Veeam Backup & Replication with object storage | Acronis Cyber Protect Cloud | Synology NAS with Hyper Backup | Cloud sync (OneDrive / SharePoint, Dropbox) | LTO tape, USB disks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Copies that cannot be changed | YesObject Lock in compliance mode, always on for at least 30 days. | If configuredObject Lock on the bucket, or a hardened Linux repository [1][2]. | If enabledImmutable cloud storage in governance or compliance mode [5]. | DependsImmutable snapshots and WriteOnce on compatible NAS models [10]; for the cloud copy it depends on the destination. | Not included by defaultVersions kept for a limited period [13][17]; Microsoft 365 Backup, sold separately, offers copies that cannot be changed and only the backup administrator can delete [14]. | DependsLTO WORM cartridges cannot be changed; USB disks offer no such protection. |
| Data in a cloud account owned by the customer | YesThe data is always in the customer's AWS account. | YesThe customer chooses where the data is kept, including their own S3 bucket [3]. | DependsUsually Acronis or partner data centres; S3 and Azure through a gateway [5]. | If configuredS3-compatible destinations or Synology C2 [11]. | NoData in the provider's cloud, in the customer's tenant or team. | Not applicableThe data is on the customer's physical media. |
| The service operator cannot read the content | YesEncrypted on the server; the Soolutions role cannot decrypt. Residual risk stated. | If enabledBackup encryption with a password managed by the customer [4]. | If enabledEncryption in the protection plan; Acronis does not keep the password [6]. | If enabledClient-side encryption available in Hyper Backup [11][12]. | Not included by defaultSpecific features with limits: Double Key Encryption [15], Dropbox encrypted folders on some plans [19]. | DependsRequires encryption in the backup software or the drive. |
| Recovery without the original infrastructure | YesA browser and an authenticator app are enough; in an emergency, standard restic with 2 of 3 shares. | With a Veeam serverFor object storage, a Veeam server, even a new one, must import the repository; an extract utility exists [3]. | Yes, for filesFiles can be downloaded from the web console, but not whole disks [7]. | YesRecovery with Hyper Backup Explorer, installed on a computer [11]. | YesRecovery from the browser, within the plan's version history limits [13][18]. | With the hardwareRequires the tape drive and the backup software, or the physical disk. |
| Cryptographic erasure of one client's data, with a statement | YesPer partition, with two approvals and a PDF statement following NIST SP 800-88. | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented | NoWORM media require physical destruction or degaussing. |
| Log and notification on every recovery | YesMandatory reason, hash-chained log, an email for every download. | DependsLog and email for every restore with Enterprise Manager or Veeam ONE, a separate product [8]. | LogActivity log; restore emails can be enabled only for Microsoft 365 and Google [9]. | Not documented | LogMicrosoft Purview audit log [16]; Dropbox not verified. | NoRequires an organisational procedure. |
| Second-person approval | YesAlways for erasures; configurable for downloads above a threshold and full copies. | For deletionsFour-eyes authorization on deletions and, on hardened repositories, on reduced immutability, depending on the licence; not on restores [1b]. | Not documented | Not documented | Not documentedMicrosoft 365 Backup alerts the other administrators [14]. | NoRequires an organisational procedure. |
| Agent identity bound to the TPM | YesNon-exportable key in the TPM, with a certificate issued by the customer's CA. | Not documentedAgents use TLS certificates [4b]. | Not documented | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Data in EU regions | YesThe configuration rejects regions outside the EU. | DependsOn the repository the customer chooses. | SelectableEuropean data centres are available [5b]. | DependsNAS on site; Frankfurt is available for Synology C2 [12b]. | DependsEU Data Boundary for EU tenants [16b]; Dropbox EU on request for eligible teams [18b]. | DependsThe data stays wherever the customer keeps the media. |
Where the alternatives do more
- Veeam and Acronis protect virtual machines, whole systems, databases and applications, including full system restore. AmbraVault protects files.
- Acronis also offers endpoint security features. A NAS is also used to share files in the office.
- OneDrive, SharePoint and Dropbox are mainly for working on files and collaborating, as well as recovering them.
- Today AmbraVault supports Windows Server only. Support for Linux and NAS is planned but not yet available.
How to read this comparison
We compare the features AmbraVault was designed for. It is not an overall assessment of the products: each solution has its own strengths and may be the right choice elsewhere.
Available features can vary with the version, the licence and the configuration.
If you find something wrong, write to amministrazione@soolutions.io: we will check it, correct the comparison and update the date.
Product names belong to their respective owners and are used only to identify the products. None of the vendors took part in preparing this comparison or approved its content.
Sources and assumptions
Public documentation consulted on 20 November 2026.
Assumptions: product versions available on that date; Veeam with an S3 object-storage repository; Acronis in the Cloud edition sold through partners; Synology with Hyper Backup to the cloud; OneDrive and SharePoint in a business Microsoft 365 tenant; Dropbox on a team plan.
For AmbraVault the reference is the product's technical documentation at version 0.1 (requirements, security, costs).
- [1] Veeam, Immutability for object storage: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/hiw_immutability_os.html · [1b] Four-eyes authorization: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/four_eyes_authorization.html
- [2] Veeam, Hardened repository: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/hardened_repository.html
- [3] Veeam, Importing backups from object storage: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/osr_import_backups.html · Object storage repository: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/object_storage_repository.html · Extract utility: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/extract_utility.html
- [4] Veeam, Encryption: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/userguide/encryption_hiw.html · [4b] Agent certificates: helpcenter.veeam.com/archive/backup/120/agents/agents_signed_cert_tls.html
- [5] Acronis, Immutable storage: acronis.com/en-us/support/documentation/CyberProtectionService/immutable-storage.html · [5b] Data centers (DE, FR, CH, IT): acronis.com/en/data-centers/
- [6] Acronis, Encryption: acronis.com/en/support/documentation/AcronisCyberProtect_17_Cloud/encryption.html
- [7] Acronis, Downloading files from cloud storage: acronis.com/en/support/documentation/CyberProtectionService/downloading-files-from-cloud-storage.html
- [8] Veeam Backup Enterprise Manager, Notifications on restore operations: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/vbr/em/em_notifications_on_rest_ops.html · Veeam ONE (separate product), Restore operator activity: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/one/userguide/restore_operator_activity.html · Backup alarms: helpcenter.veeam.com/docs/one/userguide/backup_alarms_events.html
- [9] Acronis, Activities: acronis.com/en-us/support/documentation/CyberProtectionService/activities-dashboard.html
- [10] Synology, WriteOnce and immutable snapshots: synology.com/dsm/software_spec/snapshot_replication
- [11] Synology, Hyper Backup: synology.com/dsm/software_spec/hyper_backup
- [12] Synology C2 Storage: c2.synology.com/en-global/storage/overview · [12b] C2 Object Storage: c2.synology.com/object-storage/overview
- [13] Microsoft, Restore your OneDrive: support.microsoft.com/en-us/onedrive/restore-your-onedrive
- [14] Microsoft 365 Backup: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/backup/backup-overview
- [15] Microsoft Purview, Double Key Encryption: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/purview/double-key-encryption
- [16] Microsoft Purview, Audit log activities: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/purview/audit-log-activities · [16b] EU Data Boundary: learn.microsoft.com/en-us/privacy/eudb/eu-data-boundary-learn
- [17] Dropbox, Version history: help.dropbox.com/delete-restore/recover-older-versions
- [18] Dropbox, Rewind: help.dropbox.com/delete-restore/rewind · [18b] Data storage location: help.dropbox.com/security/physical-location-data-storage
- [19] Dropbox, Encrypted team folders: help.dropbox.com/security/encrypted-team-folders